Vatan NJ – Gujju Beggar in Jersey City Serves Superb Food with Rotten Service

When it comes to begging, none can beat Indians.

With several centuries of diligent practice behind them, Indians have honed begging into an art form.

Not long ago, we were at the receiving end of one such beggar in Jersey City, NJ.

We were standing on Newark Ave in Jersey City (NJ) considering which of the two Indian restaurants – Horn OK Please or Vatan – should be deified by our presence when a man in black suit jumped out of Vatan and begged us to come in.

$8.99 only, Waijatariyan pood, Pliss come, Pliss come. Pure Waijatariyan, the man ejaculated in that stupid accent unique to semi-literate Gujjus.

And his face had that anxious, pained, constipated expression Gujjus sport between two visits to the Swaminarayan temple.

Since the milk of human kindness overfloweth in our breasts, we decided to give our Tandoori Chicken and Lamb Vindaloo craving taste-buds a rest and bless Vatan with our benign presence.

Vatan Jersey City Dal TadkaVegetable Tikka Masala, Dal Tadka & Naan

Barely a few months old (it opened on the Hindu festival day of Diwali), Vatan has no fancy ambiance to speak of.

Six booths to the left (as you enter), a few tables on the right and a small room with floor seating!

The restaurant is obviously not doing that well because despite the menu stating $14.99 as the weekend buffet price, the actual cost is only $8.99 on Friday (goes up to $11.99 on Sat & Sun).

Vatan’s owner Nikhil claims he intends to raise the price in May once business picks up.

Ha ha ha. Fat chance. Keep dreaming, Nikhil!

Who’s gonna pay $14.99 for a Vegetarian Indian buffet on that ugly trash dump aka Newark Avenue in Jersey City.

Vatan – Delicious Indian Food

If you can endure the desi beggars plus the dirty stench and ambiance of Newark Ave,  Vatan is da place for a fine Indian vegetarian meal in North New Jersey.

The food at Vatan screams with such flavor that at the end of our meal we gave thanks to all the Swaminarayan gods for giving us such a fine Indian restaurant in New Jersey.

South Indian staples of Upma and Sambar, North Indian curries like Vegetable Tikka Masala, Baingan Bartha, Tadka Dal, Gobi Alu Mutter, Poori, Naan Bread and Gujarati specialties like Kadi, Moong and Dudh Pakh all made their way swiftly and effortlessly into our cavernous stomach.

Whether it is South Indian, North Indian or Gujarati you are a winner at Vatan (with the exception of the ghastly Naan bread).

Crispy, Spicy Onion Pakoras

Onion Pakoras were crisp and, for a change, they were not the bland atrocities you are doled out at most Indian restaurants.

They were spicy with sliced green chilies coming into the mouth.

Adding to the flavor was the accompanying Green Chutney.

Delicious Upma and Authentic Sambar

Rarely do North Indian restaurants deliver on the South Indian front. But Vatan delivered, and so wholesomely.

Upma was hot and spicy with a nice flavor of curry leaves and tomato. The evenly cooked Upma without any lumps of Rava left us squealing in ecstasy over this South Indian delicacy.

Vatan’s carrot-onion Sambar was a medium thick work of art with a fine flavor of dhania, black pepper seeds and coconut and evoked memories of all the good things of life.

Our only grouse was that the Sambar was lukewarm.

Spicy Baingan Bartha, Tangy Vegetable Tikka Masala

Surely, the medium thick spicy Baingan Bartha must have been prepared by God’s own chef.

So perfect were the proportions of tomato, onion and roasted eggplant.

Thoroughly relished with both Poori and plain rice.

Vegetable Tikka Masala was a creamy delight with onion, capsicum, potato, turnip.

Tangy, spicy and extremely flavorful, it was the pièce de résistance of our meal.

We devoured this North Indian curry with both plain rice and Poori.

Vatan Newark Ave FoodUpma (foreground) and Moong (background)

Divine Gujarati Kadhi

The sweetish and spicy Kadhi with a slightly watery texture was simply divine and we drank it a la soup.

Flavorful Moong and Tadka Dal

The well soaked and cooked Moong was flavorful but a trifle bland compared to other vegetarian curries jewels on the table.

What was not to like about the Tadka Dal with the whole boiled spinach leaves in it. Maybe, we’d have enjoyed it more had it come with chopped spinach.

Horrible Naan Bread, Hot Poori

Weekend lunch at Vatan comes with a choice of Poori, Roti and Naan Bread.

Being greedy desi bastards we asked for both Poori and Naan Bread which turned out to be a smart move in retrospect. You see the four small puffed up Pooris came hot to the table and we enjoyed them with all the curries.

Vatan PooriPoori with Curries

But the eight piece Naan bread was a complete disaster and was surely prepared by the devil’s apprentice. Naan bread was crisp like Dosa and came cold to the table. Much as we abhor wasting food (given the many beggars who go hungry daily), we had no choice but to show the middle finger to Vatan’s Naan bread.

Watery Dudh Pakh, Delicious Shrikhand

Dudh Pakh with sliced almonds, cashews and pistachios was flavorful but way too watery.

Since we did not relish the texture of Dudh Pakh we topped off our meal with Shrikhand and Masala Chai.

Vatan ShrikhandShrikhand with Toppings

Throwing all calorie and Cholesterol concerns to the winds, we dug into the Shirkhand bowl that was topped off with pistachio toppings. Much recommended, folks.

Masala Chai came hot to the table with a nice aroma of spices.

Vatan – Poor Service and Unhygienic Dining Room Practices

While we enjoyed every single item laid out on the lunch table what got our goat at Vatan was the poor service and some unhygienic dine-in practices.

Though there were hardly any diners, our waiter took an eternity (15 minutes) to get us Poori and Naan Bread. When the Naan Bread finally landed on our table, it was cold. Second, they never bothered to clear the used plates piling up on the table.

As if this indifferent service was not enough, what sickened us was that the wait staff did not care to stop diners who were carrying their used plates to the buffet table and refilling it.

Neither the Hispanic waiter nor the owner Nikhil, who was dicking around with some folders at one of the booths, made any effort to stop diners from such unhygienic practices.

Yeeks! It is these kind of unhygienic practices that result in potential contamination of food and turn into a health hazard for other unsuspecting diners.

Will the New Jersey Health Department please look into the unsanitary practices at Vatan and levy a hefty fine on the restaurant.

Vatan – An Indian Jewel

Its hygiene and service shortcomings notwithstanding, SearchIndia.com considers Vatan an Indian jewel in New Jersey for its authentic, fine Indian food.

We can’t wait to revisit this mecca of Indian cuisine on Newark Avenue in Jersey City.

2 Responses to "Vatan NJ – Gujju Beggar in Jersey City Serves Superb Food with Rotten Service"

  1. Naveen   February 22, 2011 at 2:20 pm

    That is a lot of food! do you hunt in packs? 😉

    SearchIndia.com Responds:

    In the event of a nookulear holocaust, we should be able to survive without eating for three weeks at the minimum. 😉

  2. soothsayer   April 4, 2011 at 4:01 pm

    This is so harsh and you tend to get personal in your reviews (almost all of them). Maybe you are just trying to be funny (I wonder if it’s working!).

    I stumbled upon this site to find some good Indian restaurants and I agree with you that most of the Indian restaurants in NJ suck.

    But I do think, there is a better way to say it.

    I think the subjectivity of these reviews detracts from their credibility. Sometimes the service is indifferent and the food mediocre, but that could be a bad menu selection and a bad attitude on the part of the customer. Truly professional wait staff are hard to find in this country, you have to be nice to them, and help them do their jobs well. Anyway, this is just my observation. This is your site and your wish. You can do whatever you want. Peace!

    SearchIndia.com Responds:

    1. You write: This is so harsh and you tend to get personal in your reviews

    Sweetie, what you slam as harsh we call fact or plain-speaking in our language.

    BTW, isn’t every review a reflection of the personal experience of the reviewer?

    2. You write: I think the subjectivity of these reviews detracts from their credibility. Sometimes the service is indifferent and the food mediocre, but that could be a bad menu selection and a bad attitude on the part of the customer.

    So even if the service is indifferent or the food mediocre at an Indian restaurant the paying customer is supposed to just grind his/her teeth and bear the travesty, is that right?

    Well, not all Indian diners are masochists pleading Whip Me, Whip Me, Please Whip Me More the moment they enter the portals of an Indian restaurant in NJ!

    And, pray, what is this business of ‘subjectivity of these reviews.’

    3. You write: Truly professional wait staff are hard to find in this country, you have to be nice to them, and help them do their jobs well.

    Stop finding excuses for the Indian restaurants in NJ.

    Today, you ask us ‘to be nice to them, and help them do their jobs well.’ We won’t be surprised if tomorrow you exhort customers to don an apron and pitch in for a few minutes in the kitchen. 🙁

    Your writing makes you sound like an apologist for crappy Indian restaurants in NJ although you do agree that most of them suck. Weird contradiction or the milk of human kindness must be overflowing in your Indian breast!

    A lot of them have no right to even call themselves restaurants.

    And if the Indian restaurateurs find it so hard to hire professional staff, they always have the option of abandoning their $$$ dreams and working as toll booth collectors or gas station attendants.

    After all, NJ still has full-serve at all gas stations. 😉

    4. You write: This is your site and your wish. You can do whatever you want.

    The only thing you got right in your comment.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login